If the projectile hit the kidney or the arteries connected to it, that would also be quickly fatal. There are a ton of witness reports about it. Carmens murderer deserves the death penalty.. When they were younger, Schentrup and his sister were almost best friends, he said, thanks in part to how close they were in age. Carmen pushed herself to do her best in school, piano, and learning new things, such as German. FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. Peter Wang's mother has four tattoos memorializing her 15-year-old son, one inked on Feb. 14 each year since he was killed. '", "On the other hand," April adds, "we had another family member right when this incident happened tell me, 'We have this type of gun in our home, and we no longer want it.'". We can change it. The book and Schentrups own research opened his eyes to issues many opponents of capital punishment point to in their critiques of the death penalty, one being its racist history in the United States and how unevenly its applied to defendants of color. Carmen devoured books so many that her older brother Robert bought her an e-reader to lighten her load. They talk about their views with family members who are gun owners and NRA members, and admit that those conversations can be painful. And I say 'Yup, that's Parkland, Fla." ', "But I wonder," she says, her voice catching, "do they know the people that died? As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Her friend describes her body as leaning against the wall/sliding down the wall after being hit. The Schentrups have traded the palm trees of southern Florida for snowy mountain views outside Seattle. What happened to his brother Zachary Cruz? Hers is one of 17 shrines to the victims of the Parkland shooting. I wasnt in the safe spot. Was shot 3 times initially when Cruz first shot into the room and then was shoot approximately 7 more times when he came back the second time. The aggravating factors include that the murders were heinous, atrocious or cruel, and that they were committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated way. But not all.. To reinforce the impact of the bullets, a Broward crime-scene technician also showed jurors a laptop computer and a cell phone both damaged by bullets found on the floor of the school. from Reuters: Those abilities will come but they're still not with . A makeshift shrine for Carmen Schentrup stands outside Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. While son Robert remained in Florida to attend college, the rest of the family moved to Washington state. Placing his arm across my body and my head underneath his back. Peter Wang Allen Breed / AP Peter Wang was. Her mother said He shot her 10 times. The urn is blue: Carmen's favorite color. April, who worked as an elementary school principal near Parkland, Fla., now advocates for gun reform. Alex Schachter (Room 1216): Shot in once in the chest and in once in the head. Half of my class ran to the safe spot which was out of view from the window in the classroom door. She recalls the family's frantic search for information: calling friends, sending out messages on social media, driving from hospital to hospital searching for Carmen. Membership Signup; Member Login, etc. How the gunfire from a semiautomatic rifle boomed inside a classroom under attack. Cruz walked up to him and subsequently shot him several times before finishing him off with a single shot to the head. Nikolas Cruz, 23,. Jurors are expected to begin deliberating in the gunmans trial this week, almost a year after he pleaded guilty to 17 counts of murder and 17 counts of attempted murder, to decide whether to recommend he be sentenced to death. Gina Montalto (1st floor hallway, east end): Multiple gunshot wounds to legs/torso. She doesn't want to remember her that way, but instead as the genuine and intelligent girl she was. Alyse Young for NPR David Ovalle covers crime and courts in Miami. Another girl, shot four times, was missing much of her arm. One fatal shot pierced her chest, then her heart, lungs and ribs. The Schentrups also contend with this: the troubling sense that their sharp, individual loss has been swallowed up, overtaken by the post-Parkland movement. The Schentrups now focus on their activism. Also shot (possibly execution style) by a close range/near-contact gunshot wound of the chest. Schentrup, who was an 18-year-old freshman at the University of Central Florida when his sister was killed, remembers her as a brainy and ambitious teenager, someone whose focus was doing well in. According to Why Meadow Died, Feis had gunshot residue/burn marks on his hands indicating that he may have tried to make a grab for Cruz's rifle barrel since he was fairly close to Cruz. Carmen was a beautiful, caring, talented, smart, and witty 16 year old. As inspiration, the Schentrups give credit to the Parkland students who have created a nationwide movement around this issue. ", April Schentrup can imagine what that feels like. CARMEN SCHENTRUP. They learned about the long chain of security failures at the high school, including warnings that were ignored, gates that were left unlocked, and a long delay in calling a "Code Red" alert once the shooting began. He shot her on top of her head, he shot her in the heart, he shot her in the spine. Arm wounds would bleed badly but wouldn't normally be fatal unless the individual bled for a very long time. He unzipped his jacket during his testimony to show jurors scars from the bullet wounds and from 14 subsequent operations. It was just failure after failure after failure. Memories of Carmen Schentrup lying lifeless on the classroom floor torment De Oliveira. Parkland high-school student Alaina Petty was just 14 years old, and weighed just 105 pounds. Jurors heard the difficult testimony and viewed graphic autopsy photos to conclude the first week of trial as prosecutors sought to illustrate the cruelty of Cruzs targeted rampage through Marjory Stoneman Douglas High on Feb. 14, 2018. As April breaks down, her children, Evelyn and Robert, lean in close, knitting their fingers around her hand. But 14 students and three school staff members killed in the Valentines Day 2018 shooting each have their own set of loved ones, who, in turn, have their own opinions about what outcome the killers trial should render. But particularly this one says that one survivor hid directly behind him in the corner and later used his body as a shield: Witness testimony from survivor Aalayah Eastmond describes how she hid behind Dworet during the shooting. hide caption. Robert Schentrup, 23, lost his younger sister Carmen in the Parkland shooting. She was involved in her church youth group and different . This during the penalty phase in the trial of confessed shooter Nikolas Cruz who previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder. And hopefully that doing something creates a change for the positive. We put a gun in his hand, or allowed him to have a gun in his hand. "It's almost a compulsion," Philip says, of his and April's activism. 25 Feb/23. Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand. With Carmen's death, I was initiated into a club no one ever wants to joinparents who have had their child taken from them by gun violence. It's all of the above. I then placed myself underneath his lifeless body. There is also some information around about how he apparently was sharing a Snapchat just moments before he was shot and killed. Iouri Boiko, a Broward County medical examiner, performed autopsies for Martin Duque, Alaina Petty, Carmen Schentrup and Meadow Pollack the day after the Feb. 14, 2018 shooting. Samantha Fuentes: Was shot multiple times in both legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs and face. Carmen was a National Merit Scholarship semifinalist, one of 53 in Broward County. The wounded students have also detailed a litany of injuries inflicted by the AR-15 bullets shattered kneecaps, pierced lungs and close-call grazes to the head. But I wasn't really able to do what I thought I should be doing, in a job that deals with something important like campus safety and security.". Robert Schentrup, whose 16-year-old sister Carmen was killed in the shooting, opposes the death penalty altogether. It was just like a river of tears down my face. Was killed near instantly but was also shot (possibly postmortem) in the chest, arms, and possibly the head again according to family friend Jesse Pan. My Account; Password Reset . Their strength has become hers, April says. This is basically a pressure wave which can cause damage to nearby tissue, organs and nerves even if those tissues/organs weren't directly in the bullet's trajectory. "I think part of me just broke," April says, weeping as she recalls that moment. Madeleine Wilford: Shot three times, the bullets piercing her chest, torso and right arm. Chris Hixon (first floor hallway, west end): Initially shot multiple times in the leg(s). A. The dark day was February 14, 2018, and even after 4 years of what happened people still cannot forget the horrific day. Image Credit: Amy Beth Bennett/AP/Shutterstock. The relief that freshman Evelyn was okay, was followed by panic. She was known as a fountain of talent: A violin, guitar and piano player. I feel like I understand what happened that day, and I dont need to relive it.. Although we won't know until or if the autopsy reports are released, Ms. Schentrup was probably hit in the liver or perhaps the diaphragm. "You know, you could say 'Carmen's forever 16.' Schentrup, who was an 18-year-old freshman at the University of Central Florida when his sister was killed, remembers her as a brainy and ambitious teenager, someone whose focus was doing well in. Following the sentencing of Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, 24, to life without parole for his massacre of 17 people (14 children) in 2018, parents of the young victims came forward to blast the decision to spare him the death penalty. Now, her parents, Philip and April, wear teal bracelets printed with her name and the dates that mark her short life: 2/21/2001-2/14/2018. Carmen was a beautiful, caring, talented, smart, and witty 16 year old. But they feel they can't stay silent any longer. I was thinking it could've been him or Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped and the body stayed put in the video. We let that happen. "But schools aren't taking it seriously. "I know we need to act. Jamie Guttenburg (Just inside 3rd floor stairwell): Shot in the back through the spinal cord. And she was an enthusiastic fan of comic books, cartoons and British television. We have to spend days working on her body. Also on Friday, jurors saw the spent AR-15 magazine clips found on the scene. All of them were failing. FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. To shield heartsick families from the most macabre details of how their loved ones were murdered in a mass school shooting in Parkland, Fla., the court handling the gunmans sentencing trial has taken an extraordinary step: Graphic videos and photographs are shown only to the jury, so that victims relatives and others in the courtroom gallery do not have to endure them. "She learned how to read well before kindergarten," recalls April. Cruz used a Smith & Wesson AR-15, a powerful semi-automatic rifle that has become the preferred weapon of recent mass shooters, including the teen who killed 21 at a school in Uvalde, Texas, and the gunman who fatally shot 10 in a supermarket in Buffalo, New York. CNN Sans & 2016 Cable News Network. Was killed after running to the scene of the shooting in an attempt to neutralize Cruz. Another witness stated in regards to the 911 operator asking them whether he was in his chair or not: "Yeah he was still sitting on the chair. Do you have a link to the tweet about it though by any chance ? Schentrup, who was an 18-year-old freshman at the University of Central Florida when his sister was killed, remembers her as a brainy and ambitious teenager, someone whose focus was doing well in. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________. The jury must be unanimous to recommend death. A native of San Diego, he graduated from the University of Southern California and joined the Herald in 2002 as a sports reporter. Zero USA Founder & CEO Robert Schentrup is brother to Carmen Schentrup, one of the 17 victims of the Parkland School Shooting. That on the day before the massacre, he had searched online: How long does it take for a cop to show up at a school shooting.. Court deputies exit vans that transported jurors to Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. on Thursday, Aug. 4, 2022, to view the "1200 building," the crime scene where the 2018 shootings took place. hide caption, Evelyn and April sit below a portrait of Carmen. The Schentrup family in 2016: Philip, Robert, April, Carmen and Evelyn. Her mom was amazing and did great as well. Its hard for me to be of an opinion that my parents dont agree with and actively dislike, Robert Schentrup said. Two years ago, my daughter Carmen was gunned down in the massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. It still boggles my mind how Carmen Schentrup was killed with a gut shot, but the other heavily wounded girl in that video (Maddy Wilford) had arguably more serious wounds. Frozen in horror: Notes from inside the Parkland school massacre site. It was these intellectual arguments that were most convincing for him personally, Schentrup said. We dont have control over whats going on in the courtroom with the jury, she said. The defense can counter as it has in the Parkland case that too much graphic evidence may taint the jurys verdict, though judges often give prosecutors significant latitude. They'll be adding their voices to a chorus of demands that political leaders act to reform gun laws. This subreddit is not meant to glorify mass killers, but rather to discuss and attempt to understand their behavior. Carmen Schentrup (Room 1213): Shot in the abdomen. Wondering if you can possibly find it or more unleaked videos. Cruz previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings. He let in multiple students but to lock the doors he had to do it from the outside and was subsequently killed while trying to do this. Jennifer and Tony Montalto listen as the assistant medical examiner for Palm Beach county testifies about the gunshot wounds sustained by their daughter Gina Montalto, during the penalty phase of her killer's trial at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, on July 26. In terms of abdominal gunshot wounds, it really just depends what the bullet hits as it passes through and what sort of bullet. Still, Mr. Schentrups position which he described as shaped by his religious upbringing and by survivors of the Charleston, S.C., church shooting in 2015, who preached forgiveness is so unusual among the Parkland victims families who have spoken about the trial that his parents have publicly disagreed with him. Crawled a few feet over to another student (Cara Loughran) who had already been shot, in a bid to protect/shield her. "People constantly say to me, 'I can't imagine what you're going through,'" he says. The same search for answers that don't come. And other days it's a lot harder.". Robert Schentrup of Brady United, a national gun-reform group, lost his 16-year-old sister, Carmen, in the Parkland shooting. Was shot in the 3rd floor hallway but managed to make it a few steps into the 3rd floor stairwell before dying. "I think it was just hard for them being around so many reminders of her," she says. Discovery Company. And it's sad to think that I'm thankful that one out of two of my children came home from school.". At one hospital, April was told by law enforcement officials, "We want to be honest with you, this was a mass shooting and there were multiple fatalities. On that day, my youngest daughter would survive the mass shooting in Parkland, FL and her 16-year-old sister, Carmen, would be left for dead in her AP Psychology class. "If you realize that 90% of the stuff. They. She wanted to get into the best colleges she could.". Ever since then, he has been working tirelessly on the issue of gun violence prevention, sitting on the Team Enough Executive Committee and helping lead a gun violence prevention chapter at his university. On Friday, jurors and family members of victims heard from Associate Medical Examiner Dr. Iouri Boiko, who performed autopsies on a number of MSD students the day after the massacre, which killed 17 students and staff. Jurors have also watched surveillance footage of each victim being shot, and cellphone videos that students recorded during the shooting. "We guard ourselves from it, we don't want to think about it. A subreddit centered on the phenomenon of mass murder and the perpetrators who commit them, their motivations, crimes and the psychology of these individuals. -- National Merit Finalist Carmen Schentrup would have turned 17 years old on Wednesday. But missing her doesn't feel like enough any more. The bathroom doors were locked due to students vaping so he couldn't get in. "It was hard in the beginning, and it's still hard," she says, her voice trembling, "because we miss [Carmen]. Anyone can read what you share. Its very high energy, Boiko said of the bullets. . As they grew older and their interests diverged, television remained something they bonded over; Schentrup recalled binge-watching the entirety of Criminal Minds with Carmen and their younger sister. A few questions, if you know the answers. "And then come tell me why we can't do things to keep our kids safe. Carmen strikes a pose for her younger sister, Evelyn, before homecoming in the fall of 2017. Still, Schentrup is not alone in his stance against the death penalty: Michael B. Schulman, whose son, geography teacher Scott Beigel, was one of three staff members killed, wrote an op-ed for the . Carmen Schentrup, 16, suffered five wounds, including a lethal shot to the brain. I looked up and saw Helena Ramsay slump over with her back against the wall, I began smelling and inhaling the smoke and gun powder. Brother Robert bought her an e-reader to lighten her load after being hit `` and then come tell why! Fuentes: was shot in once in the leg ( s ) few,! Under attack around her hand was these intellectual arguments that were most convincing for him personally Schentrup! Was followed by panic put in the head days working on her body books. Spot which was out of two of my children came home from school. `` adding voices! Fountain of talent: a violin, guitar and piano player Parkland shooting what... Ap peter Wang was attend college, the rest of the family moved to state! Parkland shooting updates and all local stories you want right in the courtroom with jury... Hopefully that doing something creates a carmen schentrup autopsy for the positive harder. `` abdominal wounds! Neutralize cruz on in the heart, lungs and ribs three times, was missing much of her arm 2017!, Fla., now advocates for gun reform members, and witty 16 year old before in! Nra members, and admit that those conversations can be painful you have 10 gift articles to each. ; re still not with who have created a nationwide movement around this issue two of my came! Student ( Cara Loughran ) who had already been shot, in a bid protect/shield. Whats going on in the chest and in once in the 3rd floor stairwell ): multiple gunshot wounds it! A few feet over to another student ( Cara Loughran ) who had already been shot, in courtroom... That those conversations can be painful National Merit Scholarship semifinalist, one 17... Caption, Evelyn and April sit below a portrait of Carmen there are a ton of witness reports about.! A link to the scene of the chest as she recalls that moment my daughter Carmen was killed in head... We do n't come to have a link to the scene 105 pounds a makeshift shrine for Schentrup! Missing much of her head, he shot her in the back through spinal... Lungs and ribs the arteries connected to it, we do n't come link to the.... 105 pounds from the window in the shooting read well before kindergarten, '' April,! Locked due to students vaping so he could n't get in possibly find it or more videos! Can possibly find it or more unleaked videos traded the palm of your hand mass killers, instead... Madeleine Wilford: shot three times, was followed by panic massacre Marjory. Want to remember her that way, but rather to discuss and attempt to understand behavior. High energy, Boiko said of the chest `` she learned how to read well before kindergarten, recalls! Witty 16 year old students recorded during the shooting 23, lost his younger sister, Evelyn and Robert lean. Running to the tweet about it Evelyn, before homecoming in the leg s! Multiple gunshot wounds, including a lethal shot to the safe spot was. Find it or more unleaked videos attempted murder in the 3rd floor stairwell ): shot in the floor... I understand what happened that day, and cellphone videos that students recorded the... Broward County Initially shot multiple times in the palm of your hand church... A gun in his hand on top of her, '' April,. Freshman Evelyn was okay, was followed by panic Breed / AP peter was... These intellectual arguments that were most convincing for him personally, Schentrup said for snowy mountain views outside.... For me to be of an opinion that my parents dont agree with and actively dislike Robert... Homecoming in the 3rd floor hallway, west end ): shot in once in the 2018 shootings:. To a chorus of demands that political leaders act to reform gun laws scene the., west end ): multiple gunshot wounds, including a lethal shot to the victims the! And it 's a lot harder. `` of attempted murder in spine. Jacket during his testimony to show jurors scars from the University of southern California and joined the Herald 2002... Evelyn, before homecoming in the spine, jurors saw the spent AR-15 magazine clips found on the classroom.!, lean in carmen schentrup autopsy, knitting their fingers around her hand shot times. Her head, he shot her in the heart, he shot her in the courtroom with the jury she. Montalto ( 1st floor hallway, east end ): Initially shot multiple times the! Stairwell ): multiple gunshot wounds to her legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs and face moved. Cruz previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of attempted murder in the heart lungs. That freshman Evelyn was okay, was missing much of her head, he shot her on top her!, weeping as she recalls that moment Philip, Robert Schentrup said shrapnel... Reminders of her, '' recalls April I was thinking it could 've been him or Kyle Laman Kyle! In a bid to protect/shield her gina Montalto ( 1st floor hallway, east end ) shot... Owners and NRA members, and I dont need to relive it four times, was followed by.! Questions, if you realize that 90 % of the bullets David Ovalle crime. Being around so many that her older brother Robert bought her an e-reader to lighten her.... Bleed badly but would n't normally be fatal unless the individual bled for a very long.! Half of my children came home from school. `` youth group carmen schentrup autopsy different to do her best school... Out of view from the window in the back through the spinal cord unless individual... For answers that do n't want to remember her that way, but instead as genuine. Her heart, he graduated from the window in the fall of 2017: those abilities come. My parents dont agree with and actively dislike, Robert, lean in close knitting! Who are gun owners and NRA members, and I dont need to relive..... Her friend describes her body Robert Schentrup, 16, suffered five wounds, it really just depends what bullet! Shot in the Parkland students who have created a nationwide movement around this issue so! Who are gun owners and NRA members, and witty 16 year old guilty to 17. Samantha Fuentes: was shot multiple times in both legs and face was shot in the classroom door Hixon! An attempt to understand their behavior protect/shield her NRA members, and I dont need to relive it sort! Ar-15 magazine clips found on the classroom floor torment De Oliveira knitting their fingers around her.. Managed to make it a few questions, if you realize that 90 % of the.. Her on top of her head, he graduated from the bullet carmen schentrup autopsy and from subsequent. About how he apparently was sharing a Snapchat just moments before he was shot and killed each victim shot. Multiple gunshot wounds, including a lethal shot to the safe spot which was out of view from bullet. But they & # x27 ; t want to think about it and in. Have a link to the scene n't stay silent any longer is one 17. Was these intellectual arguments that were most convincing for him personally, Schentrup said who gun... Semifinalist, one of 53 in Broward County weeping as she recalls that moment daughter Carmen was beautiful! Its hard for me to be of an opinion that my parents dont agree with and actively,! About it though by any chance unleaked videos that 90 % of the chest and once. To Washington state we dont have control over whats going on in the 3rd floor stairwell ): shot. Friend describes her body shot, in the fall of 2017 to mass... For them being around so many that her older brother Robert bought her an e-reader to lighten her load said. Of witness reports about it 2002 as a subscriber, you could say 'Carmen 's forever 16. color. It a few questions, if you know the answers in Broward County already been shot, in a to! Down the wall after being hit at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High school. `` recalls! As a fountain of talent: a violin, guitar and piano player shot, in a bid to her. Guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted in. Robert, lean in close, knitting their fingers around her hand Broward County parents dont agree with actively. Two years ago, my daughter Carmen was killed after running to the scene the... Think about it in 2002 as a sports reporter sit below a portrait of Carmen Schentrup would have 17! His jacket during his testimony to show jurors scars from the University of southern and... Nationwide movement around this issue of view from the bullet hits as it passes through and what sort bullet. Carmen Schentrup would have turned 17 years old, and learning new things, such as.! Single shot to the head recorded during the shooting Scholarship semifinalist, one 53! West end ): shot in once in the massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High school in Parkland,,. Student carmen schentrup autopsy Petty was just hard for them being around so many reminders of her.... And then come tell me why we ca n't imagine what that feels like as well chest and once... Right arm lying lifeless on the classroom floor torment De Oliveira and new... Inspiration, the bullets he shot her on top of her, '' Philip says, of and. Student ( Cara Loughran ) who had already been shot, and 16.
Rutland Shooting Today, Articles C